I Rank TOP Brow Mascaras. Which One Proves Best?

best brow filler

Hey there!

Are your eyebrows unmanageable and you struggle everyday to keep them in place? Are you looking for natural-looking brow products but can’t find the right one? Would you like to fill in your brows and make them appear thicker and more voluminous so that they look flawless all day? Well, I definitely recommend reading my roundup of the best brow mascaras. You’ll pick out the most suitable brow product so that you can always be happy with your makeup looks.

Eyebrow makeup is a beauty topic that we could talk about all day. If I were to tell you about my attempts to find the best brow fillers, it would take me long hours. I’m not going to bore you with the things that proved failures. The key thing is I finally know how to define my brows and which brow products never let me down.

It took me a long time to come up with a topic for the new post. I wanted to surprise you, and eventually decided to create a ranking of top brow mascaras that I have tested and can share some details 🙂

I’ve been using brow mascaras for a long time and I really like the results such products create. Makeup is done fast, they’re easy to use, and I don’t need to know how to fill in brows step by step… I just take hold of a brow mascara brush and let it do the job! 🙂

You should know that eyebrow mascara will solve any problem you’re having with doing your brows. The unwanted gaps will be gone, and the defined yet natural-looking brows will put a smile on your face for sure!

Now make a cup of your favorite tea and get to reading!

Brow Mascara. Why This Very Product?

Good brow mascaras are very likely to become makeup essentials for any girl. Are you wondering why so many go for eyebrow mascara? Let me round up the reasons!

  • IT IS EASY TO USE – application of eyebrow mascara is like applying a regular mascara on lashes; we only need to remember to put more product on the end of brow to make sure we get natural-looking results.
  • IT CREATES NATURAL-LOOKING BROW MAKEUP – eyebrow pencils are more likely to create overdone cartoonish eyebrows; with brow mascara, we can reach every hair thanks to a comfortable brush.
  • IT MAY GET US THICKER-LOOKING BROWS – some brow mascaras from my roundup will definitely help you get fuller, thicker-looking eyebrows.
  • IT IS COMFORTABLE TO USE – using brow mascara, we apply brow makeup worry-free… We simply open the mascara tube and apply it on our brows. Doing the brows is now possible in the most uncomfortable circumstances.

TOP 6 EYEBROW MASCARAS THAT CAN GET YOU GORGEOUS BROWS

1) NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA

nanobrow shape mascara review

Eyebrow makeup as if applied by a pro…

I got this brow mascara by accident and I didn’t think it would be so great on my brows. The Nanobrow Shape Mascara made me fall in love with my brows all over again. Makeup is so much better and this product lasts up to 24 hours, keeping brows flawless. I thought such results can only be achieved by a makeup artist! As soon as I took hold of the Nanobrow mascara, my brows were precisely filled in; I also gave them the desired color and shape. The precision of the brush caught my eye immediately; it allows me to reach the shortest brow hairs, which was always impossible with previous brow products I used. There are no smudges or clumping.

Thicker-looking, extremely voluminous brows…

Every time I use the Nanobrow Shape Mascara, my brows look thicker and more voluminous, and don’t need any touchups… They’re just right 🙂

Anyone will love it…

I believe this is the best brow mascara for everyone, no matter if you have thin brows or patchy brows that you’re fed up with. I heartily recommend the Nanobrow Shape Mascara for the long-wear makeup looks, superb results and natural colors 🙂 Recently my mom started to sneak mine and says she may buy it too; she’s not easy when it comes to brow products!

SIZE: 7 ml

PRICE: attractive

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: www.nanobrow.us; I’ve heard some cosmetics stores have this brow mascara (Sephora may be worth checking).

2) BENEFIT COSMETICS GIMME BROW+

benefit cosmetics brow mascara review

Take your pick…

This brow mascara offers a wide range of colors. There are really lots of them so at first I had no idea which one to pick. Eventually I got a few and I like the result. The shades are natural and subtle.

Filled in brows…

With the Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow+, I can get fuller-looking brows. This brow mascara camouflages all gaps easily, however, many times I had to literally take off the clumps from my brows… The product tends to flake so I think some of you won’t enjoy wearing it.

Long-lasting, subtle results…

The brow mascara stays on my brows for many hours and keeps me from worrying about their looks. The formula is gentle on the skin and I guess it will be suitable for those complaining about redness after some brow products.

SIZE: 3 ml

PRICE: high

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: I think it was Sephora (brow mascara from BENEFIT COSMETICS is widely available)

3) LANCOME SOURCILS STYLER BROW MASCARA

lancome brow mascara review

Takes control of brows and nourishes…

As soon as I got the thickening brow mascara from LANCOME, I liked the light texture. I can tame my unruly brows without leaving them weighed down or stiff. I think the added rose extract needs to be appreciated; its conditioning properties make brows appear healthier.

Easy use, hard choice…

Getting the right shade of this brow mascara was tricky. I guess there are some problems with availability because it took me a long time to find the best one. All in all, I picked out the clear mascara and it was a good choice. It has a comb-like applicator which is very comfortable to use. We can create brow makeup for all occasions fast.

It lasts long yet not the longest…

To be honest, I thought it would create longer-lasting makeup. I hoped it would let me keep the brows under control all day but it failed to do that. Eyebrows keep neat for around eight hours. I’ve seen online reviews with girls saying it stays put all day so maybe it depends on the brows…?

SIZE: 6.5 ml

PRICE: affordable

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: at some online beauty store

4) KIKO MILANO EYEBROW FIBERS COLOURED MASCARA

kiko brow mascara review

Precisely-shaped brows…

I decided to give this brow mascara a try when my bestie got it. I hoped for wow results without effort, however, there was no thickening and volume-increasing effect. Instead my brows looked neat and every hair was in its place, so to say.

A mini brush which causes mixed feelings…

Well, I didn’t like the brush in this brow mascara. It applies the product evenly but takes more time. I prefer mascara brushes that are trouble-free and most of all let me apply the brow mascara fast.

Lasts as promised…

The time the brow mascara stayed put was a pleasant surprise! I didn’t need to worry about touch-ups. Applying it in the morning before work, it looked like there was a little less of it during late hours. That was the moment when I wanted to take it off anyway so I was happy with the result.

SIZE: 4.2 ml

PRICE: attractive

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: I got it at some beauty store where I live. I’m sure it’s available online too.

5) YVES SAINT LAURENT COUTURE BROW MASCARA

ysl brow mascara review

Get the defined brows…

If you don’t know how to fill in brows, then this brow mascara will help you out. It’s easy to use and comes with a comfortable brush, which is why we can comb through brows and give them desired shape easily. It creates makeup that defines the brows yet still looks natural.

The texture is disappointing…

Too bad I didn’t like the consistency. The brow mascara from YVES SAINT LAURENT tends to cause clumping and smudging. We need to be careful not to apply too much. Compared to other brow mascara I had, this one stacks up worst.

Good color range…

Still, I need to mention one more pro. The available colors blend with natural hair color and I think there’s a shade for anyone.

SIZE: 7.7 ml

PRICE: quite pricey

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: I got it at Sephora and I’m sure it’s widely available online. 

6) CLINIQUE JUST BROWSING BRUSH-ON STYLING MOUSSE

clinique brow mousse review

Natural-looking brow makeup in a moment…

I liked this brow mascara the least, but I wanted to share what’s best about this very product. It creates very subtle natural-looking brow makeup without the cartoonish look. I mention that because – contrary to what you may think – there are many brow products that leave brows looking funny. 

Stiff brush…

This brow mascara has a stiff brush which irritates my skin. That wasn’t nice. I’m a fan of soft-feeling brushes.

Not good for unruly brows…

I’m positive that this brow mascara won’t work for unmanageable brows that need taming. To me it’s a good brow product if you want to define your brows enhancing their color but you don’t expect wow results.

SIZE: 2 ml

PRICE: high

WHERE I BOUGHT IT: I can’t remember, it was Sephora or Douglas maybe. I know it’s available at many stores, also online.

Application of Brow Mascara Step by Step… Using the Best Brow Mascara!

You already know which brow mascara is going to become a part of your makeup kit, right? Cool! Now that you’re past the hardest thing – the choice of the best brow product – it’s time you learnt how to use brow mascara. It is uncomplicated and should be trouble-free even for those of you who always thought brow makeup was super tiring and time-consuming. I believe that brow mascara is the best choice for women who have little experience in filling in brows. At the same time, it’s a great product for professionals who can use the best eyebrow mascaras in their salons.

Here’s brow mascara application step by step:

  1. Open your brow mascara tube.
  2. Using the mascara brush, start combing through the brows, ideally start at the inner side of the brow.
  3. Keep brushing and apply the product evenly.
  4. Remember to always use more mascara on the end of the brow (it should be done with most brow products) to create natural-looking brow makeup without brows looking funny and overdone.
  5. Let the product set. If you feel like it and want more definition, then you can apply one more coating of the brow mascara following the above steps.
  6. Done! Now you know how to use eyebrow mascara! 🙂 

I guess you won’t be surprised if I say that brow mascara is my makeup essential. I believe you will pick a product from my roundup and it will work great for you too.

We can take control of the most unmanageable eyebrows, and we can get perfectly-defined brows every time we use makeup. You don’t need to settle for less; a good brow product should fulfill all of your expectations! 🙂

Has any brow mascara caught your eye? Or maybe you are still a brow pencil person?

Please share your brow makeup experience and let me know what brow products you’re using.

Take care and keep coming back! 🙂

Give a Comment